These two poems were of particular interest to me because
they both featured children that are wise beyond their years. In the first
poem, a young school girl is trying to make sense of the world around her and
her culture. She does not understand why she is being taught certain subjects
in school and specifically raises questions about marriage when she says “How
will I sleep with him, I who have never slept away from my mother?” (11). The
girl has a wonderful imagination and pictures a different life for herself but
is never able to achieve it because she is suppressed due to her culture which
is seen as she writes on her tablet. “There is something else we were born for.
I almost remember it. While I write, a ghost writes on the same tablet,
achieves a different sum” (13). Her culture will always have an impact on how
she acts, presents herself, and thinks.
The second poem is similar but different in a few specific
ways. It features a young boy whom also has a lot of questions in regard to his
culture, specifically his religion. He is continually questioning his father
about Mohammad and asks such questions as “But why did he go to the mountain?
What happened to him?” (25). The boy also starts to question his faith when
things are not going well with little sign of improvement. He asks Mohammad, “Are
you angry with us? Do you think my father forgot you?” (27). At the end of the poem, we learn that despite
having so many questions and possible doubt about his religion and culture, the
boy still continues to believe. He even wishes to one day to be united with his
friends on the mountain with Mohammad (29).
While the boy in this poem questions his religion, the girl
in the first poem questions her education and her roles as a woman. This is
what makes the two poems so different and interesting. Due to the different
gender roles in the cultures, the boy and the young girl concern themselves
with two different aspects of their culture. In this way they are lost and both
are trying to figure out where they stand and what their place in this world is
going to be. Since they are of different genders, their answers to these
questions will be different. They may never find the answers they are looking
for but they both seem rather determined to keep searching.
This reminds me of myself growing up and many other children. They always have questions about the world and their culture. Nye raises some important questions through children, a much safer and less controversial way.
ReplyDelete