The style that the two others choose to write their books
was quite interesting and is what really set them apart. “When The Emperor Was
Divine”, was a book that was written off of factual information, history, and
stories that the author had heard from relatives that actually were placed in
the holding camps. “Citizen 13660” was different in that the author was telling
readers about her own personal experiences in the camps. The way that they
books are written are so different because of the personal experiences that the
two women have gone through. Since their personal experiences are so different,
with some minor similarities, the two others were bound to have taken on two
completely different writing styles.
“When The Emperor Was Divine” was written more like a novel,
with a plot with a distinct beginning, middle, and end. The second book was a
picture novel but was very factual. It was written all off of the authors
experiences while in the camps with minimum background information and ends
abruptly with the author being released from the camp. The two different styles
also probably have a lot to do with how the two authors handle the trauma and
violence of the camps. Otsuka is able to write in a more “story- like” way because
she did not experience these horrors personally and may have made it easier to
write a book with a lot of details and additional information. Okubo
experienced everything in her book first hand, and may have wanted to stick to
the bare facts, avoiding a lot of personal or familial background. It is tough
to say if these are the real reasons why the others choose these styles of writing,
but in either case there was a lot of overlap in historical details and both
effectively got the message across about how horrible these camps were.
I also noticed that Otsuka's novel was more "story-like" and entertaining than Okubo's picture-novel. Reading "Citizen 13660" first was better than if I had read "When the Emperor Was Divine" because of they style choices. Okubo was very informative, less tied up in the drama and issues. It gave me a basic understanding of what Japanese Americans suffered through. As I read Otsuka's novel the writing style was more complex but easy to understand with the knowledge I gained about interment camps.
ReplyDelete